Curated Selection
Every item that comes through our doors is evaluated for quality, condition, and style. We don't fill our racks with anything less than something worth buying.
Our Story
More Than a Consignment Shop —
A Kenmore Staple
Painted Lady Consignment sits on Delaware Avenue as a destination for thoughtful shopping — where quality meets value, and where every item is chosen with intention.
We believe that the best finds aren't mass-produced. They're discovered. Whether you're hunting for a statement piece of clothing, a unique home accent, or a gift that stands out, our curated selection changes constantly and always surprises.
As a consignment shop, we partner with our community. Sellers bring in what they no longer need, and we handle the rest — pricing, display, and sale — so everyone wins. It's a cycle that keeps great items in rotation and keeps prices fair.
Curated
Every Piece
Fair
Seller Terms
Local
Since Day One
Why Painted Lady
The Difference Is in the Details
Fair & Transparent
Clear consignment terms, honest pricing, and timely payouts. We treat your items the way we'd want ours treated — with respect and integrity.
Constantly Rotating
New arrivals every week. No two visits are the same. The best consignment shops never stand still, and neither do we.
Community Focused
We're right here on Delaware Avenue — part of the neighborhood fabric. When you shop or sell with us, you're supporting a local business that cares.
Consignment
Turn What You Don't Need
Into Something Worthwhile
Selling your gently used items with Painted Lady is straightforward, fair, and designed to work for you.
-
01
Bring Your Items
Drop off quality clothing, accessories, jewelry, or home goods. We accept items in excellent condition that we're confident will sell.
-
02
We Handle the Rest
From pricing and photography to display and marketing — we manage every detail so you don't have to lift a finger.
-
03
Get Paid
Once your item sells, you're notified and paid promptly. It's that simple — no hidden fees, no surprises.
Inside the Shop
Something New Awaits
Our inventory is always changing. Here's a glimpse of what you might discover.
Visit Us
Find Us in
the Heart of Kenmore
Address
3147 Delaware Ave
Kenmore, NY 14217
Kenmore, NY 14217
Phone
(716) 877-7300
Hours
Monday – Saturday
10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
10:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Sunday: Closed
Contact
We'd Love to
Hear From You
Have questions about consignment, want to schedule a drop-off, or just want to say hello? Reach out anytime.
Message Sent!
Thank you for reaching out. We'll get back to you as soon as possible.
